Providence - 03/29/2014

5955 Melrose Avenue
Los Angeles, CA 90038
(323) 460-4170

I didn't expect to find myself back at Providence anytime soon but the meal was my prize for a bet made three years ago and it was long past time to collect. Naturally nothing less than the 16-course Chef's menu would do and we were fortunate enough to snag the chefs table.

angry angelino - blanco tequila, fernet branca, ginger, lime, house made jalapeño bitters
love is a rose - gin, lillet rose, perfection tangerine, passion fruit, honey, prosecco
libre - buffalo trace bourbon, averna, cassis, chocolate chili bitters, orange twist
lazy days - aperol, mandarine napoléon, fresh rhubarb, lambrusco bianco secco
I was a bit curious how the cocktails would hold up as longtime bartender Zahra Bates left for Cole's Red Car Bar after five years at Providence. My favorite of our quartet was the Angry Angelino, almost petrol flavored, the cocktail has a bitter herbaceous bite from the jalepeno softened with the spice from the ginger. Bursting with fresh lively passion fruit and a sweet effervescence, the Love is a Rose would have made a wonderful summer sipper. The Libre exuded a woody herbal heft shaded with the slightest hint of chocolate and orange. The Lazy Days was another light fresh cocktail that gives off pure mandarin notes with a touch of bitterness thanks to the Aperol.


dark and stormy
Providence typically starts the meal with a modernist twist on a cocktail. I found the dark and stormy to be an upgrade from their former signature greyhound spherification. The ginger foam has a touch of prickly heat to compliment the pleasing candied sweetness of the rum jelly.


scallop nasturtium
Think of this as a sushi taco. The delicate nasturtium is filled with a mix of cured scallop tartare, puffed rice, and sushi rice. The creamy sweetness of the scallop is readily apparent upon mastication while the "taco shell" brings a subtle twinge of herbaceous savor.


middleneck clam - chorizo
Our third amuse came in a rather elaborate presentation wrapped in seaweed and served on a bed of ice. The dish is initially dominated by the smoky sour twang of the chorizo, but a thread of dark of dark earthy salinity makes itself felt on the back end of the bite.


2002 Pol Roger Extra Cuvee de Reserve, Champagne, France
Rather than go with the typical pairing, my companions and I decided to bring a few bottles we'd been saving for a special occasion. First up was a 2002 Pol Roger, the wine shows off yeasty toasty notes that are almost Krug-like in their intensity though as the wine warms I detected a bit more minerality and citrus.


wagyu tartare - grilled foccacia, black truffle
The Wagyu tartare was every bit as decadent as I expected it to be, fatty and supple, with a hint of luxuriously earthy truffle. The grilled foccacia had a crisp and toasty texture and slight bitterness, a lovely counterpoint to the beef.


petit pois - smoked halibut bone dashi
This next snack was a lovely study in contrasts. The broth was made from slightly smoked halibut bones giving it a thick creamy mouth feel and buttery saline umami reminiscent of Chinese gao tong. By comparison the peas brought a sweet bright levity all wrapped up with a taut snappy texture.


shigoku - american caviar
I typically prefer my oysters raw but a perfectly cooked one has its own charms. The Shigoku was noticably softer with a slicker mouth feel. The flavor is initially dominated by the caviar but there is a persistent melon-y sweetness that lingers on the finish.


abalone and miso
sword squid and chorizo
The skewers remain unchanged from my previous visit. The abalone is definitely the more subdued of the duo, coupling a deep ocean-y savor with a hint of sweetness. The squid and chorizo exudes a powerful savory twang while the squid acts more as a textural element, snappy and dense but fairly mild.


chips and dip - salmon skin crisp, heavy cream, chives, ikura
Next up was a playful rendition of "chips and dip." The salmon skin has a lovely crunch but is a bit too salty on its own. The mixture of chives and cream deftly tempers the aggressive saltiness of the chip


cigar - wagyu, mirepoix, feuille de brick
Cimarusti and company really went all out with the snacks, serving up 9 consistently delicious snacks to start the meal. The last treat was definitely on the heavy side with a rich savory mixture of beef and vegetables reminiscent of a beef stew all wrapped in a crisp delicate shell of feuille de brick.


japanese saba - pickled ginger, carrot, coriander, cucumber
Conceptually, this course remains largely unchanged from my previous visit, but I thought the execution was a bit more on point this time. The key here was the use of pickling brine as a sauce for the fish, the added acidity brought out the tangy flavor of the vegetables putting them on equal footing with the oily heft of the mackerel.


2003 Didier Dagueneau Pouilly-Fumé Silex, Loire Valley, France
Our second wine was a real eye-opener for me. Never a fan of Sauvignon Blanc, the Silex showed all the ripe honeyed tropical notes the varietal is known for, but with a chalky minerality that kept the wine fresh rather than heavy or cloying.


uni & abalone - buckwheat, farm fresh egg
Our second course was a seafood-infused riff on the classic eggs and truffle. The creamy scrambled eggs form a gentle savory base for the luxurious seafood while the mixture of cooked and puffed buckwheat gives the dish some body and textural variation.


santa barbara spot prawn - white asparagus, caviar, jurancon
This was a more composed spot prawn dish than I'm used to seeing from Cimarusti. The prawn itself exudes a pristine sweetness augmented by the intense salinity of the caviar. The tender asparagus shoots have offer a lateral vegetal sweetness while the jurancon sauce is simultaneously sweet, buttery, and tart.


alaskan king crab - risotino all'onda, preserved black bean, black pepper, orange zest
The risotto was probably the weakest course of the night for me. I was expecting a delicate course highlighted by the king crab but any shellfish flavor was overwhelmed by the earthy ponderousness of the black bean. The citrus does provide some relief but I found the combination with the black bean a bit jarring.


wild king salmon - salsify, black truffle, baby leek
The meal got right back on track after that little hiccup with the risotto. The salmon belly came out the perfect temperature with a deep red center. Unsurprisingly the fish was tender and brimming with oily goodness. The accompanying sides were a multifaceted blend of sweet salsify, tender creamy leeks and sharp tangy shimeji mushrooms all wrapped up with the subtle earthy musk of black truffle.


1996 Louis Jadot, Bonnes Mares, Burgundy, France
Our final wine of the night was a delicious 1996 Bonnes Mares from Jadot. The wine has plenty of both bright cherry and molasses and cola-like sweetness on the nose. Hints of underbrush and earth keeps things balanced making for a complex vibrant and thoroughly enjoyable wine.


wild french turbot - california morels, almond, miners lettuce
Moving onto the heaviest dishes of the night we started off with a wonderfully cooked Turbot. The meat showed off the characteristic density I was expecting along with a bit of extra fatty relish. The clean salinity of the fish works well as a baseline for the fresh herbaceousness of the succulent greens as well as the deep forested flavor of the morels. A very straightforward but beautifully executed and immensely enjoyable dish.


miyazaki wagyu - roasted baby carrot, shallot confit, shiitake mushroom
No dinner at Providence would be complete without some Japanese Wagyu. The meat has noticeable but not overwhelming marbling which made for a very balanced flavor profile between charred meaty goodness and pure fatty decadence. The sides were an interesting mix and while I quite enjoyed fragrant shallots and the woody kick of the shitake, the carrot was a touch too sweet for my liking


artisanal cheeses
We were a bit lazy about getting down all the cheeses but the quartet was fairly safe across the board, my favorite ended up being the truffle cheese which I believe our server called Sottocenere.


blood orange - yogurt bavarois, guava jelly rhubarb, hibiscus
Moving onto desserts we started with a fun palate cleanser of fruit and yogurt. The flavors are an intense gamut ranging from tart to sweet all held together by the malolactic tang of the yogurt.


japanese cheesecake - huckleberry, black sesame/soy-milk ice cream
Our second dessert was a cheesecake done with an Asian riff. The black sesame gives the dessert a flavor reminiscent of tong yuan while lemon curd brings a sharp countervailing acidity.


dulcey cremeaux - spiced genoise, sunchoke, cocoa nib
Our second main dessert was a cremeaux made from Valrhona Dulcey chocolate. The blond chocolate is definitely on the lighter side with more caramel and buttery notes than the typical chocolate. The spiced cake added a nice weighty warmth to the treat while the sunchoke chips brought just the right amount of intrigue and savor to the dish.


chocolate marquis - dark chocolate flourless cake, white chocolate foam, chocolate chantilly
Our final composed dessert was a more traditional chocolate dessert built around a seductive base of dark chocolate cake though the flavor of milk and white chocolate each make their unique presence felt as well.


mignardises - peppermint macaron, sunchoke caramel, lychee pate de fruit, brown butter madeline, chocolate truffles
The meal ended with a beautiful presentation of candies and small pastries. While all the mignardises were quite tasty, the caramel was the most interesting of the candies thanks to the savory twist of sunchoke.


fire and spice - cocoa nib infused tequila ocho plata, ancho reyes ancho chile liqueur, l.b.v. port, mexican vanilla, orange oils
I decided to end the meal with a cup of cappuccino but one of my companions needed something a bit stronger. The fire and spice does show hints of its namesake heat but there is also a strong citrus undertone and hint of sweetness making this a well suited as an after dinner tipple.


I didn't think Cimarusti could outdo last year's meal at Providence, but so far each successive trip to Providence has been stronger than the one before. Perhaps like the Biblical Sampson, Cimarusti draws strength from his hair though in this case its the magnificent beard hes been growing for the past year.