Coi - 11/21/2008

373 Broadway Street
San Francisco, CA 94133
(415) 393-9000

The second stop on my 2-star tour through San Francisco. I was a bit apprehensive looking at the menu at Coi especially with regards to some of the early courses. From the exterior you'd be hard pressed to tell this was even a restaurant. From the window, there is a view of the bar which makes the restaurant almost look like a lounge or waiting area. Entering the restaurant, we walked through the bar into a small windowless dining area. The rectangular room is flanked by two benches lengthwise with small tables that seated either 2 or 4 people. The whole dining area seats around 20 people and when we arrived almost all the tables were taken up by couples or pairs of couples, I had no idea the restaurant was such a hot date place.




Still recovering from the debauchery that was Totoraku, I have been trying to limit my alcohol intake. I ended up splitting a couple of beers with my dining companion. He started with a Coi Aperitif rather than his traditional Mojito. The aperitif was fairly light, with no single distinguishing flavor, very refreshing. Our first beer was the 2007 Gouden 'Carlous Grand Cru of the Emperor' from Belgium. The beer had a thick head when poured and gave off an intense nose of caramelized sugar and apple cider with similar notes on the palate. Next we tried a Kiuchi Brewery Hitachino Nest 'Red Rice' from Japan. All I could taste when drinking this was olives both the aroma and taste were dominated by loads of green olive. Our last beer was the Fantome Saison from Belgium. This started with a really unpleasant funk on the nose but very light grassy citrus and apple on the palate. After a while the funk dissipated and was replaced by a cidery nose. In the glass the Fantome had a cloudy haze that quickly settled to the bottom of the glass.





Amuse: Milk & Honey - Elysium Flower
This reminded me very much of the liquid olives and liquid cherries at Bazaar. The suspension inside the thin membrane lived up to its name. A light sprinkling of salt gave the morsel a pleasing salty finish.


Bread - House made wheat roll
The bread was surprisingly traditional for such an adventurous restaurant, I expected a variety of bread a la Bastide. The bread was almost hot to the touch with a crunchy flaky exterior and a soft spongy interior and a yeasty nutty flavor was fairly typical of a wheat bread. My companion liked the bread so much he ended up eating 6 helpings.


01: Pink Grapefruit - Ginger, Tarragon, Black Pepper
Visually simple the plain appearance hides a complex ballet of flavor and sensation. Besides the food was a dab of Coi perfume, made from the same ingredients as the dish. We were told to dab a little on our wrists as the aromas would heighten the flavor of the food. The perfume did smell strongly of citrus with some of the herbal spice from the tarragon and ginger. The white sphere is actually made up of multiple layers a foamy icy exterior wrapped around a creamier sorbet with fresh grapefruit beneath. The dominant flavor is the grapefruit although supporting hints of licorice are apparent once the initial burst of crisp fruit subsides.




02: Shiny Beets - Citrus Scented Gel, Vadouvan
Never a fan of beets this was still an interesting study in the ingredient. I liked the orange the best of the three for its milder sweetness and better harmony with the vadouvan. I had a dish with vadouvan the previous evening at Aqua and I felt the spice was too intense, here the vadouvan had a similar flavor but more smoothly integrated into the dish as a whole.


03a: Fromage Blanc Tart - Chicories, Black Olive
The cheese was slightly foamy and had a very soft flavor with a good amount of creaminess nicely heightened by the olive. I particularly enjoyed the crust of the tart which was quite hard and crumbly with a butteriness.


03b: Oysters under Glass - Marin Miyagi Oysters, Yuzu, Radish, Apple, Rau Ram
This reminded me of a dish I had at Alinea. The oysters were fresh and plump and the use of tart fruit and herbs added a zestiness reminiscent of a traditional migionette but not quite the same.


04: Triamble Squash Soup - Asian Pear, Pomegranate, Padron Chile Flakes, Mint
The soup was a bit too watery but it contrasted nicely with the pear and pomegranate, I thought the soup had a fairly restrained sweetness but my companion disagreed. What really impressed me about this course was the way the chile and mint further attenuated the sweetness of the dish and lingered on the tongue long after the soup was gone, leaving a tingly pleasant warmth.



05a: Garden, Late Fall - Root Vegetables, Cocoa, Herbs
This dish indeed lived up to its name, a plate of haphazardly arranged vegetables resting in cocoa "sand". As one would expect the overall dish was quite light and refreshing with a variety of vegetal flavors and textures. Still what made this dish special was the use of cocoa which added a bittersweet earthy flavor on the finish. If parents ever have problems getting their kids to eat veggies maybe they should add some cocoa powder.


05b: Roasted Cauliflower - Smoked Bone Marrow, Pickled Red Onion, Oregano
I didn't expect much out of this course but I really love what the roasting did to the cauliflower. The lightly charred top had a dry bitterness that gave way to a smoky sweet flavor when taken with the bone marrow foam. The addition of intensely tart red onions kept this dish lively and vibrant.



06: Earth and Sea - Steamed Tofu Mousseline, Yuba, Fresh Seaweeds, Mushroom Dashi
The rich mushroom dashi and seaweed actually reminded me a little of sharks fin soup. The fresh tofu was so light and airy I could barely detect it although the tofu skin had a very distinct firmness to it, like a semi-hard noodle.


07a: Sauteed Monterey Bay Abalone - Escarole, Caper Berry-Sea Lettuce Vinaigrette
I was looking forward to this the moment I saw it on the menu and I was not disappointed. We were brought a whole abalone with the top nicely browned by the sauté pan. The abalone had a thick meaty texture that was a delight to chew, my friend described the texture as in the middle between sashimi and braised abalone. The caper lettuce sauce added a tart sauce that complimented the natural sweetness of the shellfish.


07b: Matsutake Grilled on the Plancha - Potato-Pine Needle Puree
After yesterday's disappointing Matsutake dish I really needed this to be better and it was. The grilled mushroom had sharp rough crunch and grilling seemed to deepen the natural woodiness of the mushroom. A light sprinkling of black pepper gave the dish a bit of bite. The potato pine needle puree was interesting but I thought the mushroom needed no extra seasoning.


08a: Slow Cooked Farm Egg - Green Farro, Erbette Chard, Brown Butter-Parmasean Sauce
I was a bit unlucky as I ended up eating this dish second and that gave time for the egg yolk to congeal into a gel like mass. The farro was one of the strongest I have ever had, just ever so slightly firmer than a risotto, the use of Parmasean was a masterful foil for the brown butter.


08b: Bolinas Goat - Sprouted Beans, Seeds, Nuts, Wheatgrass
This dish had a wildness about it, the raw sprouts and crunchy nuts heightened the natural savoriness of the goat. I expected loads of gaminess but the meat was fairly mild. With two different preparations of goat, one braised, the other seared rare, each with their own flavor and texture. The wheatgrass puree was largely unnecessary but didn't detract from the dish either.


Supplement: Country Pork Pate - Cornichion, Grain Mustard
Being pork, the pate felt like it was made up of distinct bits of meat. Although I prefer a smoother texture on my pate the flavor was still quite good especially when taken with the tart mustard.


Supplement: Spiny Lobster Ravioli - Tarragon, Brown Butter, Spinach
These reminded me of wontons, unidentified meat wrapped by noodle. Overall the dish had a nice flavor, but the lobster was overcooked and flavorless. My dining companion was hard pressed to even identify the filling as lobster.


09: Etude (Soyoung Scanlan) - Peppercress, Fuyu Persimmon, Black Walnuts
Apparently this is an artisan goat cheese produced by Soyoung Scanlan of Andante Dairy. Each of their cheeses is named after a musical term, reflecting her love of music. I was truly impressed with this cheese, firm an fairly mild with a nutty sharpness. the use of fuyu persimmon added a lively crunch and hint of sweetness and the black walnuts added a toasted nuttiness to compliment the cheese.


Intermezzo: Mutsu Apple Rose Soda
The dish had an intense fragrance of fresh fruit and flower. On the palate it was intensely acidic almost mouth-puckeringly tart, just what I want from a palate cleanser.


10: Quince and Huckleberry Parfait - Huckleberry Ice, Almond, Lemon Thyme
The parfait by itself was fairly good, a medley of sweet and sour fruits, but what really made this was the sugary sweet and crispy walnut praline.


11: Chocolate-Mesquite Cake - Smoked Pepitas Prailine, Kabocha Squash Sherbet
A fairly simple chocolate cake and a balanced sherbet, not too sweet but smooth and creamy. I really liked the cake with its its soft warm texture with a bit of sugary grittiness. The woody pepitas added a nice crunch that complimented the cake and the slightly sweet sherbet. This is one of those rare dishes where each part is delicious and the combination is even better. A wonderful last course to a transcendent tasting menu.



Chocolate Chip Cookie Truffle
They called this a truffle but it was more like a cookie than a truffle. The morsel tasted a lot like a gob of raw cookie dough and if we mixed that with the next course would have been very much like chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream.



Tahitian Vanilla and Olive Oil Milkshake
Very tasty, as the name suggests this tasted like a rich vanilla milkshake with a slight grassy twist from the olive oil.


Coi was the meal I wanted out of Bazaar, innovative and exciting without sacrificing flavor. The ingredients in each dish worked in harmony to provide an exquisite flavor. In fact many of the ingredients I complained about at Aqua were used here to great effect. It has been quite a while since almost every course in a tasting menu has impressed me, but Coi did just that. The only misses were the supplements we ordered from the bar menu, but these were supposed to be more comfort food than fine dining. There is a definite focus on using the freshest ingredients and course change on a daily basis depending what the chef finds at the farmer's market. That the kitchen can produce such a sophisticated and well-designed menu with an ever shifting set of ingredients is doubly impressive. Our waiter told us, between consecutive days anywhere from 0-2 courses will change and within a few weeks the entire menu will be new. I will definitely make a point to come back next time in am in San Francisco. I almost wish I could wipe this meal from my memory so I can be just as amazed next time.